JSON Web Tokens (JWTs)

JSON Web Tokens (JWTs)

Why JWT?

  • We'll use JWTs for persistent authentication
  • We currently use authentication tokens to solve the same problem
  • Why do we need a new mechanism?
  • What's wrong with auth tokens??

Recall Auth Tokens

  • Server issues an auth token on login
  • Store token in database on login
  • Lookup token in database for authentication
The user/client registers a username and password with the server. The server issues an auth token in a cookie. The user/client then sends requests with the auth token to the server. The server talks to the auth database, which stores passwords and auth tokens.

Recall Auth Tokens

  • The token is opaque
    • Random meaningless bytes
  • Database lookup is required
The user/client registers a username and password with the server. The server issues an auth token in a cookie. The user/client then sends requests with the auth token to the server. The server talks to the auth database, which stores passwords and auth tokens.

Recall Auth Tokens

  • When your app gets HUGE
    • Make it distributed!
    • Separate parts of your app onto different servers
The user/client registers a username and password with the auth server. The auth server issues an auth token in a cookie. The user/client sends requests with the auth token to a separate app server. Only the auth server talks to the auth database, which stores passwords and auth tokens.

Recall Auth Tokens

  • App server needs to verify the auth token
The user/client registers a username and password with the auth server. The auth server issues an auth token in a cookie. The user/client sends requests with the auth token to a separate app server. Only the auth server talks to the auth database, which stores passwords and auth tokens.

Auth Tokens - Distributed

  • App server needs to verify the auth token
  • Option 1: Shared DB
    • App server connects to the same DB as the auth server to lookup the auth token
    • Advantage: Code is simple. Same thing we've been doing
    • Disadvantage: Slow and complex architecture
      • DB must support multiple servers
      • App must connect to the shared DB on every authenticated request

Auth Tokens - Distributed

  • App server needs to verify the auth token
  • Option 2: Server-Server Communication
    • App server sends a request to the auth server to verify the token
    • Advantage: Avoids a shared DB
    • Disadvantage: Slow
      • Every authenticated requests requires the app server, auth server, and the auth DB
      • Might as well have a monolith app (It's effectively not distributed)

Introducing JWTs

  • Instead of auth token
    • Issue a self-contained JWT
The user/client registers a username and password with the auth server. The auth server issues a JWT in a cookie. The user/client sends requests with the JWT to a separate app server. The auth database now stores only passwords.

JWT

  • JWTs are tokens that are designed to be self-contained
    • Contain all information needed for authentication/authorization
    • No need to talk to the DB or the auth server
    • Auth server doesn't even need to store JWTs
  • App server receives a request containing a JWT
    • Verify the token locally

JWT

  • JSON Web Tokens
    • Often pronounced "jot"
  • JSON
    • Contains a payload that must be a JSON object
  • Web
    • Encoded using url-safe characters
    • Can be used in HTTP headers
  • Tokens
    • Typically used for authentication/authorization
    • Can be used to solve any problem that wants tokens

JWT - Structure

  • A JWT is composed of three parts
  • Headers
    • Specifies the type of token, and algorithm used for signing
  • Claims
    • The payload of the token
    • Can contain the identity of the user (Authentication) and any scopes they can access (Authorization)
  • Signature
    • The signature of the token using the algorithm specified in the headers

JWT - Structure

  • Each of the three parts are Base64URL encoded
  • Base64
    • Maps 3 bytes of arbitrary data into 4 ASCII characters
    • 64 characters: a-z, A-Z, 0-9, '+', '/'
    • If length%3 != 0, pad with '='
    • Not suitable for the web
  • Base64URL
    • Replace '+' and '/' with '-' and '_'
    • Omit the padding
    • This avoids all url reserved characters

JWT - Structure

  • Three Base64URL-encoded parts are separated by '.'
  • eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJ1c2VybmFtZSI6IkFsaWNlIn0.Bh0...
  • This token looks opaque
    • It is not!!
  • Base64URL is not a hashing algorithm!
  • Base64URL is not encryption!
  • Your JWTs are effectively plain-text
  • This token has the claim: {"username": "Alice"}

JWT - Usage

  • JWTs are effectively plain text
  • Everyone with access to the token can see the claims
  • Anyone can generate their own tokens with any claims they choose
    • Trivial to impersonate other users
  • Need to verify that the auth server issued the token
    • Sign it!

JWT - Verification

  • The issuer (Auth server) will cryptographically sign the JWTs it issues
  • Apps will verify this signature
  • Attackers cannot forge the signatures
  • Example of a signed JWT:

eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJ1c2VybmFtZSI6IkFsaWNlIn0.Bh0qjhE-gYMC3uQOORQ7yrsjUeESQ6fBqrt5dpGXRQ5i4z9FCsN1USZVw10MFZf9XPq5mt9MLyMNSrMsvVnCFYcWONbmupgWxMi4MMkziy9LePgFosFX-SSb64mWZsE6t8MG657ZmvkmRpq7AINtOi4UZpFmpTcvNFrVRXIi8os9i6PcPbplBAyPq4a8sIxQXcLqyObr84CZQv3q67NFI-ZP0RQHu9qm65CxdchHVW7kuwTWyTvvZWNMS3Ga_9VY2QdYr8oyMAYDySCwtaL5eTk8Zm8TNiBHLCD15H8A7IQ7_r2V7cXxeXBgDXfs1DqufcEv6lSsBN1i3rat096bxlPM183zTRKD-WYHLzIJV1FTRCms4lmwYlPfDski-nX41sWIvUk2FNtuWl1QcQmR8WVxFhXtmicka4caU83iL_zlTGVTswuW5Bd6UBsJ1c9c_OBE28RnMtR23duJZsL7lTqCIn9H_7GvLrwWy1JgAp4CRqeiFR8j8vJne1XcIJJ9hJVWL-2bdbe6Iu_SAWUpmiAeXy3NfJaTibSSCANs2ple_eCY7mg1ebrGHIdNq9W3izjHwyNFAg8p5K3aNnv8rLe6yJhXg0CS94s3oLkhiEa83y4pvnjO2Adgm9o4Z3uE0Hb1nZN_LJuOWMZbdPZavmPKlTFsSzUZ_hE0AdWtabc

JWT - Verification

  • Public/Private key
    • In CSE312, we'll prefer to sign tokens with a private RSA key using the RS256 algorithm
    • This algorithm computes a SHA256 hash of the encoded headers and claims of the token
    • Sign this hash using the auth server's private key
    • The Base64URL encoding of this signature is the 3rd part of the token
  • App server has the auth servers public key
    • Use the public key to verify the signature

JWT - Verification

  • Public/Private key
    • Attackers can generate JWTs with valid headers and claims
    • Attackers cannot forge the signature
  • If the signature is not valid, do not accept the token

JWT - Verification

  • Shared Secret
    • Alternatively, all servers can control a shared secret used to both sign and verify signatures
    • If the secret is not compromised, this is just as good as private key signatures
    • Downside:
      • Expands your attack surface
        • Attacker who compromises any server has your shared secret
      • Not wise if you're issuing tokens that are verified by 3rd party servers
    • Not allowed on the project. Only your auth service may have the signing key

Registered Claims

  • RFC 7519 defines some standard claims. All are optional
    • exp: Expiration time, in seconds since 1970. Reject the token after this time
    • iat: When the token was issued
    • sub: Who the token is about (eg. the user's id)
    • iss: Who issued the token (eg. your auth service)
  • Always set exp
    • A JWT can't be revoked. Expiring is how it stops working

Verifying a JWT

  • Use a library
  • Check the signature with the auth service's public key
  • Check exp
  • Choose the algorithm yourself. Never use the one in the token's header
    • An attacker can set "alg": "none", or switch RS256 to HS256 and sign with your public key

Storing JWTs

  • Store the JWT in a cookie, the same way as an auth token
    • HttpOnly: JavaScript can't read it, so an XSS attack can't steal it
    • Secure: Only sent over HTTPS
  • Avoid localStorage
    • Any script running on your page can read it

Logging Out

  • The auth service doesn't store JWTs, so it can't delete one
  • Logging out deletes the cookie from the browser
    • A copy of the token still works until it expires
  • Options:
    • Short-lived tokens, plus refresh tokens to get new ones (Recall OAuth)
    • Any other option requires communication with the auth server or database (This is what we're trying to avoid)

Compromised JWTs

  • A compromised JWT is valid until it expires
  • Just like logging out, the auth server has no way to revoke a JWT once it's issued
  • Using short expiration times limits the damage that can be done (Typically ~1 hour)

JWT - Encryption

  • JWTs can optionally be encrypted to obfuscate the headers and claims
    • Anything can be encrypted. Sometimes, people will encrypt JWTs

Recall OAuth

  • When the auth and resource servers are separate
  • Common for access tokens to be JWTs
  • Make them short-lived and issue refresh tokens
Your app sends an authorization grant to the authentication server, which responds with an access token and a refresh token. Later your app sends the refresh token to the authentication server and gets back a new access token, and possibly a new refresh token. To use the API, your app sends only the access token to the resource server, which responds with private data.

JWTs in the Project

The Auth Service

  • A separate service, in its own container, handles registration, login, and logout
    • It has the private key and the password database
    • It issues a signed JWT in a cookie on login
  • Nginx routes /register, /login, and /logout to the auth service, and everything else to your app
  • Your app verifies JWTs with the public key
    • No request to the auth service and no database lookup

The Auth Service

The browser talks to nginx over HTTPS. Nginx routes /register, /login, and /logout to the auth service, and everything else to the app. The auth service holds the private key and the password database, and signs JWTs. The app holds only the public key, which it gets from a shared volume or a public key endpoint, and uses it to verify JWTs. The app has its own game data.

Keys

  • Generate the key pair when the auth service starts, if it doesn't have one yet
  • Store the private key in a volume that only the auth service mounts
    • Keys must survive a restart, or every JWT stops working
    • Never commit a private key
    • Not even your app server should hold the private key
  • Share the public key with your app
    • A volume both containers mount, or an endpoint on the auth service that returns it

Further Reading